I changed your recipe and now I hate it


I was looking for a recipe for a salad to take to a neighborhood picnic this weekend. My all-time favorite recipe is for a cold spinach salad with sesame oil dressing but you have to blanch and chop about 6 pounds of spinach and I didn’t want to take the time for that. Instead I searched for similar recipes on the Internet and found one I liked at  Epicurious.com. (If you’re interested, click here.)

I admit that when I’m trying a recipe for the first time, I follow the directions exactly. I want to see what the recipe is supposed to taste like before I start changing  it. So it’s surprising to read how many cooks just start tossing in their own ingredients right from the start. Granted, most of them are probably better cooks than I am.

I did read the reviews because I never know when I’ll come across an idea for a blog post, and these reviewers did not disappoint.

First, most of the reviewers loved the recipe. They might have added an ingredient or two, but not enough to make something other than what the chef had in mind.

However, if you are reviewing and rating a recipe that you’ve changed, what, exactly are you reviewing? Is it great –or bad–because of your tweaks or in spite of them?  One reviewer acknowledged this when he or she wrote: “At this point I’m no longer reviewing the original recipe, since all the modifications make this an entirely different salad.”

Another cook gave it a low, two-star (actually, two-forks) rating after making 8  (eight!) changes to this simple recipe.  “I thought the salad wasn’t really memorable,” she wrote.

Maybe that’s because she forgot what the original recipe was supposed to be.

4 thoughts on “I changed your recipe and now I hate it

  1. I agree that sometimes reviews are more interesting that whatever you were looking for. Especially when reading reviews of hotels or restaurants it can be pretty easy to see where the complaints are coming for, what kind of person is reviewing and it all becomes a big rabbit hole. Not that I don’t trust my fellow man, but I rarely read reviews any more – certainly never for recipes.


    1. I’m fascinated by the food comments and how they just toss out the recipe, change all the ingredients, and then complain about it.
      I have to admit I checked out an online review of a hotel while I was in their parking lot and about to book a room for the night. 2 reviewers said they came home with beg bug bites. Since the reviews were fairly recent, I just kept on driving.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s